As Black History Month rolls on, I asked myself a question that may seem stupid to most people: Who's black? And then I started wondering, who's not? And how is it decided? Does the individual or society determine what we are or is it a combination of both? Are there other factors? Is this the
Family Feud or actual objective science?
In 2009, all rational and educated people now accept that race is a human construct, which isn't to say that it's meaningless. As long as people are treated differently (preferentially, discriminatorily or just differently based on presupposed differences) on the basis of race, how society constructs and applies that race is worth thinking about. And, ideally, there shouldn't be any shame in recognizing broad cultural differences either. Why should "white pride" be offensive? Pride in er-one, I say. Minor caveat: to even assume that American society has reached a consensus on race defies reality – that's why Dave Chappelle instituted the racial draft. So step with me into a blog of shadows and substance, things and ideas into, to coin a phrase, the Twilight Zone.
Barack Obama, Halle Berry and Alicia Keys all chose black
Race as self-identification
Some people argue that race is primarily a self-identification. If someone views themselves as black, provided they have
some Sub-Saharan ancestry, then that's their right.
Barack Obama,
Halle Berry and
Alicia Keys all have one white and one black parent. All were abandoned by their black fathers and raised by single white mothers. All consider themselves black. I'm OK with that I suppose, in part because society tells them that they're black as well... except for Alicia Keys. I honestly thought she was a white girl with cornrows until I saw that she was in
The Secret Life of Bees. I mean, seriously, my cousin NaTisha would more likely be thought of as black.