Sings Greatest Palace Music (CD)
Bonnie "Prince" Billy
Amoeba Review
John Schacht 05/15/2010
Whatever your take on an artist re-doing his own material, one thing this collection confirms: Will Oldham disappeared completely into Bonnie Prince Billy with this release, and in the process may have made some sort of weird post-modern statement – whether by design or accident, it doesn’t really matter. The artist-formerly-known-as-Palace/Palace Brothers/Palace Music would in the future still have minimalist pictures left to paint, but this 2004 re-recording of old Palace-related material was an adventure in decidedly hi-fi twang. Devotion to Palace's warbling lo-fi and Oldham's Appalachian Hillbilly persona will quickly determine the listener’s enjoyment of this sonic do-over. Luddites will undoubtedly snip at BPB's shiny sound and the recruitment of some of Nashville's most expensive hired guns -- drummer Eddie Bayers, Hargus "Pig" Robbins (piano) and Stuart Duncan (fiddle) -- to gussy up these Palace songs, which they surely did. But Oldham has recorded some of the most honest, affecting and adult (either "adult" definition will often do) songs in recent years, be he Palace or "Prince,” and if you’d never heard the originals it seems unlikely these new versions would fail to move you because of their sheen. "You Will Miss Me When I Burn," "More Brother Rides," "Gulf Shores," and "Ohio River Boat Song" could probably be played on tuba and triangle and still transcend. One or two tunes don't make the transition well, like "I Am a Cinematographer" and "I Send My Love to You," both of which don’t benefit from new, overly saccharine takes. But most of these songs were engagingly authentic when they crawled from the hills, muddy river crossings and mining camps of Oldham's imagination; they still are here, even with a nice new gloss of Bonnie Prince on them.
Track Listing
Disc 1 Titles |
Artist |
Length |
---|---|---|
1.
New Partner
|
Bonnie "Prince" Billy | 04:31 |
2.
Ohio River Boat Song
|
Bonnie "Prince" Billy | 02:54 |
3.
Gulf Shores
|
Bonnie "Prince" Billy | 03:54 |
4.
You Will Miss Me When I Burn
|
Bonnie "Prince" Billy | 04:08 |
5.
The Brute Choir
|
Bonnie "Prince" Billy | 03:41 |
6.
I Send My Love to You
|
Bonnie "Prince" Billy | 02:28 |
7.
More Brother Rides
|
Bonnie "Prince" Billy | 03:04 |
8.
Agnes, Queen of Sorrow
|
Bonnie "Prince" Billy | 03:13 |
9.
Viva Ultra
|
Bonnie "Prince" Billy | 03:56 |
10.
Pushkin
|
Bonnie "Prince" Billy | 04:01 |
11.
Horses
|
Bonnie "Prince" Billy | 03:45 |
12.
Riding
|
Bonnie "Prince" Billy | 03:42 |
13.
West Palm Beach
|
Bonnie "Prince" Billy | 04:03 |
14.
No More Workhorse Blues
|
Bonnie "Prince" Billy | 02:56 |
15.
I Am a Cinematographer
|
Bonnie "Prince" Billy | 07:44 |
16.
Untitled
|
Bonnie "Prince" Billy | 00:04 |