Movies We Like
Struggling actor slash waiter, Michael Dorsey (Hoffman), teaches acting and coaches his friends’ auditions, but his exasperated agent (played wonderfully by director Sidney Pollack) lets him know, no one will hire him because he’s too much trouble (much like Hoffman’s own difficult reputation). After helping his needy actress friend Sandy (Teri Garr) prepare for a soap opera role, he ends up going up for it in drag and booking it, under his new stage name, Dorothy Michaels. With the help of his droll playwright roommate (an uncredited Bill Murray), keeping up his ruse as a woman becomes a fulltime job. He accidentally sleeps with Sandy, but falls in love with his soap costar Julie (Jessica Lange); she’s involved with the show’s chauvinist director (Dabney Coleman). On a weekend getaway Julie’s widower father (Charles Durning) falls for Dorothy as does her old cad costar John Van Horn (George Gaynes). Meanwhile on the set of the show Dorothy proves to be an actress who plays by her own rules, rewriting lines and following her instincts which make her an instant celebrity (I suppose once upon a time, soap operas had the ability to make their casts into names). Michael wants to put down his mask and reveal to everyone who he really is but besides ruining his now thriving career, it will complicate the relationships that he has made as Dorothy. He also begins to grasp how hard it is to be a woman in the 1980s.
Unlike Mrs. Doubtfire or Big Momma's House or most drag comedies, the comedy of Tootsie doesn’t come from Hoffman prancing around as a woman. Yes, it’s a classic mistaken identity farce but not at the expense of the dignity of women. Though Michael’s dressing-room mate (Geena Davis) is often in her underwear, Michael isn’t working the deception as a chance to ogle woman, it’s strictly out of his love of acting and need for work. Dorothy herself is a fascinating character; Hoffman brilliantly makes her believable, and though he has no inherent feminine features, it’s not hard to understand people falling for his act. Coming off Kramer vs. Kramer, this (along with his earlier one-two punch of The Graduate and Midnight Cowboy) would prove to be the peak of Hoffman’s career. Following Tootsie with the disastrous Ishtar, Hoffman would never again connect with audiences as a major leading man (though he would find acclaim as a character actor in films like Rain Man and Wag the Dog).
For Jessica Lange, then known as the fragile beauty from the Dino De Laurentiis King Kong remake, Tootsie and her performance as Francis Farmer in Francis that same year would make her a major A-list actress (she got Oscar nominations for both films and won for Tootsie). It would also mark career peaks for most of the cast including Garr, Coleman and Durning. For Murray, Tootsie would show he was more than just a goofy, slapstick Saturday Night Live comedian and the film worked as a preview to the more critically acclaimed roles to come for him. Director Sidney Pollack had always worked with A-material and major stars (most notably Robert Redford in films like Three Days of the Condor and The Way We Were); he would follow Tootsie with the overblown but admired Out of Africa and then direct a bunch of duds. His acting performance in Tootsie would lead to more acting gigs, including work in Stanley Kubrick’s Eyes Wide Shut and his fantastic turn in Woody Allen’s Husbands and Wives.
As a backstage comedy, Tootsie shined a light on the world of soaps and New York actors hitting the pavement in search of work. Hoffman never wore his fame well; he always seemed self conscious of his status and guilty about the struggling actors he left behind. Tootsie is almost a love letter to them; he’s telling them I understand your plight. And more importantly to working women the film was really feeling their pain; Michael is a guy who would like to be a seducer, but after seeing the effort that single mom Julie goes through and the struggle to make Dorothy more of a beauty, more feminine, his eyes have been opened and there will be no going back to his past life.
Tootsie was nominated for 10 Oscars including Best Actor (Dustin Hoffman), Best Supporting Actress (Teri Garr), Best Cinematography, Best Director, Best Editing, Best Music, Original Song, Best Picture, Best Sound, Best Screenplay, and won for Best Supporting Actress (Jessica Lange).