No, I haven't given up on talking
Inglourious Basterds to death; I'm almost finished, cross my heart. It's just that
Dave Fiore distracted me with thinking about how I'd rank
Lynch's feature films (
The Grandmother and
The Alphabet are probably my favorite shorts). Nothing will pull me into a conversation faster than my
favorite living director. One thing I've noticed about my enjoyment of his films is that over time it's negatively correlated with my initial reaction: the less I liked them on first viewing, the more I like them with each re-viewing, and vice versa. Another is that I prefer the ratio-narrative Lynch to the one who lets his dreams/"ideas" take him wherever (granted, many, including Fiore, don't much agree that my preferred Lynch even exists). So, in order of my enjoyment/rewatchability/hours of mental masturbation afforded:
I. Lost Highway (1997)
Well, actually, it's the first half and finale with
Bill Pullman's Fred Madison that place the film on top. For sure,
LH contains some of Lynch's weakest moments:
Balthazar Getty's Pete Dayton ("you liked it, hunh?"), music chosen by
Trent Reznor (
Bowie's "Lost Highway" over
Payne's -- really?), and a menacing cameo by
Marilyn Manson and
Twiggy (about as spooky as
W.A.S.P. in
Ghoulies 2). Nevertheless, most of Lynch's major themes receive their fullest and most direct expression here:
Vertig-inous duality (Renee vs. Alice), repression and oneiric escapism (the hallways, Fred's fugue state as a release from his impotence and murderous deed), and the demands of the always elusive Real (the intrusive mirror, phone calls, video tapes and, of course,
Robert Blake's Virgil, the white-faced Mystery Man). Some poor casting and music supervision can't ultimately diminish Lynch and co-writer
Barry Gifford's perfect construct.